Remarkable ... Martin’s assessments of Vargas Llosa’s books vary widely, but his praise of the 'truly great' writer is consistent. He is loyal to the man too, but that loyalty is more critical, and it is hard sometimes to see that the life and the books have much in common. Perhaps they don’t. And perhaps this biography is all the better for that reason ... Martin understands perfectly that to explain is often to explain away.
The result is a monumental achievement: a synthesis of his subject's personal and political life with a surgical yet shockingly breezy analysis of the writing itself.
Openly critical ... Martin was deeply disappointed, almost heartbroken, by his subject, and from time to time his judgment gets in the way of the story. ... Even so, he pulls off a monumental feat, showing how the inner forces that gave us these immortal novels also created the complicated person who wrote them.
The first part of this biography is utterly brilliant, sharply insightful on the novels and incisive on the development of this singular man, but Martin, who has also written an admired biography of Garcia Marquez, seems unable to cope with the latter half of Vargas Llosa’s life. The book becomes odder, and finally rather bad ... Martin’s problems with the Vargas Llosa of the later years stem from his inability to accept that conservatism is capable of artistic achievement ... Martin’s stridency becomes silly.
Chatty yet coolly analytical ... Martin has written a genuinely critical life. The occasional overworked oedipal reading of his subject’s affairs and an inexplicable fondness for the word 'sexy' are minor irritants in a searching, stylish account whose real subject is not merely Vargas Llosa but the intellectual and political milieux that made and unmade him.
Fiercely opinionated, noisily judgmental, maddeningly digressive, yet too excitably committed to be dull, Martin delivers not a cool formal portrait...but a late, impassioned addition to the 'boom' canon itself. Think of it as a sprawling non-fiction novel, but scrupulously accurate: an incendiary epic, on both sides, of illusions cherished and paradise mislaid ... A partisan narrator, Martin forever grinds his axe. Still, he regularly puts aside the hatchet to pick up the laurel crown ... Readers who tire of Martin’s accusatory severity — often warranted, but sometimes grumpily self-righteous — will find relief in these gentle, homespun tunes.
Authoritative ... The resulting portrait, 15 years in researching and writing, is a thoughtful, frequently critical appraisal of a rare and intense talent