Since grade school, Joseph Osmundson dreamed of being pregnant. As he grew into the queer scientist he is today, the economic precarity of academia and the warming planet led to his decision not to reproduce. That is, until a lesbian couple he had known since college came to him with a proposition: would Joe be a bio-dad and would he co-parent alongside them?
An utterly unique contribution to the often predictable genre of infertility and parenting lit ... It’s rare to read a well-researched nonfiction narrative that blends fascinating specialized knowledge with sharp political critique and a moving, gripping personal story. It’s even more rare to read one that is unafraid to move beyond nonfiction into the realm of fantasy.
Blends memoir and science writing in this moving meditation on queer family, the climate crisis, and 21st-century child rearing ... Though Osmundson’s story takes some heartbreaking turns, the mood is more inquisitive than melancholy: his reflections teem with the restless curiosity of someone who’s devoted their professional life to asking questions. The result is at once edifying and affecting.
Despite pulling from excellent queer theorists, he does little to broaden the conversation of family. He reaches toward empathy and openness, but the arc bends back toward the self ... A narrative of queer parenthood that doesn’t quite cohere.