The question of Biden’s general competency during his Presidency is a crucial one; doubts about his fitness ended his campaign for reëlection, after all. But Promise Me, America treats all such inquiries as extraneous and gratuitous ... The news of the memoir, in short, is that there is no real news: Biden is as stubbornly in denial as ever. And that assessment risks making the book sound more interesting than it is ... Startlingly dull ... Much of it has the feel of something written by a committee—and a committee of which Biden himself need not have been a member ... He had it in him to write a great book about the loss of his own powers as he aged, and how it led him to lash out at people like Hur, who said what they saw, and at allies who loved him but knew that he was done. He might have found a way to be grateful for a debate that, aberration or not, insured that he wouldn’t take the oath of office with an undiagnosed case of cancer, and regretful that he didn’t depart the stage even sooner. That this memoir is not that book is a literary as well as a political tragedy.
Biden...is neither reflective nor repentant. He does not concede mistakes, and seems to regret almost nothing ... It is no small irony that the book is coming out during a moment of Democratic jubilation, one in which the party seems eager to move beyond what it once was. But now Democrats are being visited by a Ghost of the Party’s Past. The book is a reminder of the painful intramural debates that marked an ultimately failed attempt to hold the presidency. It is also a reminder of how stubborn Biden remains.
Joe Biden wants you to know that he is proud of himself — and if his new memoir is any indication, he thinks everyone else should be proud of him, too ... The result reads like a mix of cover letter and campaign speech — one that’s more than 400 pages long ... You have to marvel at such formidable powers of compartmentalization.