PanThe New YorkerThe question of Biden’s general competency during his Presidency is a crucial one; doubts about his fitness ended his campaign for reëlection, after all. But Promise Me, America treats all such inquiries as extraneous and gratuitous ... The news of the memoir, in short, is that there is no real news: Biden is as stubbornly in denial as ever. And that assessment risks making the book sound more interesting than it is ... Startlingly dull ... Much of it has the feel of something written by a committee—and a committee of which Biden himself need not have been a member ... He had it in him to write a great book about the loss of his own powers as he aged, and how it led him to lash out at people like Hur, who said what they saw, and at allies who loved him but knew that he was done. He might have found a way to be grateful for a debate that, aberration or not, insured that he wouldn’t take the oath of office with an undiagnosed case of cancer, and regretful that he didn’t depart the stage even sooner. That this memoir is not that book is a literary as well as a political tragedy.
PanThe New YorkerView from the East Wing is full of blind spots. She doesn’t persuade; she just insists and elides ... Perhaps because so many important things are missing from the book, there is a lot of filler, even though the book isn’t long (two hundred and sixty-six pages, generously spaced). We are provided with a long list of the amenities at Camp David and the texts of various press releases ... There is a lot of Joe in the book, and yet not much of him doing the work of governing—deliberating, balancing the concerns of foreign and domestic allies, making the big calls. The question of who did, and who decided, what in the Biden Administration is not a conundrum that the former First Lady seems ready to help resolve.
Rory Carroll
PositiveThe New YorkerA reminder of just how much the Good Friday Agreement accomplished ... It’s hard to render an episode in a centuries-old struggle as a caper story, but Carroll lets in just enough history to pull it off, mostly.
David Nasaw
MixedThe New YorkerOn July 23, 1945, less than three months after Germany’s surrender, Earl Harrison, the dean of the University of Pennsylvania Law School, sat down at Bergen-Belsen with a survivor named Yossel Rosensaft ... The State Department had sent him as a special emissary to investigate the conditions in the camps that were hastily being organized to shelter \'displaced persons,\' or D.P.s, and to report back \'with particular reference to the Jewish refugees\' ... What Nasaw calls \'the Last Million\' were the \'non-repatriable\' remnant who refused to leave or had nowhere to go ... There is something of a lacuna in Nasaw’s book where one might expect them to be, given that they were, by many definitions (although not necessarily the one used by the occupying forces) displaced persons, too. Nasaw notes the phenomenon, observes that many ethnic Germans had collaborated with the Nazis, and reports that there was \'little debate and no dissension\' about the expulsion when it came up at Potsdam. Otherwise, the expellees remain at the margins of his story.