... disturbing and necessary ... describes with great empathy the lives of workers who do jobs that they themselves find morally horrifying ... [Press] ushers us into a world of moral nuance and psychological complexity that behavioral science rarely captures ... Press’s visceral descriptions of the treatment of mentally ill prisoners are agonizing to read ... Press exhorts us not to look away from our dirty secrets but rather to take responsibility for the 'dirty work' being done to meet the sicker needs of our society. At the same time, perhaps unwittingly, he leaves some doubt as to whether a humane 'us' who will take such responsibility is attainable. Such doubt would go against the spirit of his book: Doubt is a corrosive force; skepticism about the moral capacities of human beings is self-fulfilling. Press would presumably accept that there are times when our faith in one another doesn’t come naturally; it must be willed. It’s a testament to his insight and vision that in spite of the ugliness to which he exposes us on almost every page, he still makes us want to set aside cynicism and pessimism and join him in finding ways to strengthen the moral bonds between us, however flawed we might be.
... makes a powerful case that, instead of vilifying dirty workers, Americans must reckon with what is being done in their name ... muddies the moral lines that many readers might unconsciously maintain, showing their complicity in labyrinthine, deeply unfair systems where the privileged never have to get their hands dirty ... about weighty moral questions, but it's also about people, profiling dozens of workers and empathetically engaging with their crises of conscience. While never absolving his interviewees, he forces readers to ask themselves whether, under similar circumstances, they would have behaved any differently. Dirty Work is not a comfortable or comforting read, nor is it meant to be. Instead, it is a rigorously argued, compassionately framed moral appeal that for some readers might serve as a wake-up call.
Press, a good reporter and even better writer, introduces us to people who have worked these jobs, without the harsh judgment they have encountered elsewhere ... Workers like Juanita remain largely out of sight and out of mind, which enables their victimization. Press contrasts this with workers at Google who forced changes by raising a stink about the company’s collaborations with China and other bad actors interested in limiting individual freedom. These, he notes, were highly skilled workers not easily replaced. When they stood up for themselves, they won ... Press suggests that the public could bring similar pressure against the purveyors of dirty work by refusing to keep looking the other way. The 'tacit mandate' he posits is 'important . . . but not set in stone. The attitudes and assumptions that it rests upon can change, and indeed have changed'...One way to make this happen is by getting to know dirty workers as people. Dirty Work gives us a guided tour.
Pulling information from sociological and economic studies, sometimes moving between sources at a dizzying pace, Press constructs a fascinating through-line ... As Press' book clearly demonstrates...shared sacrifice is a myth that has 'never been honored as faithfully in practice as in theory.'
... powerful ... Press argues convincingly that economic inequality 'mirrors and reinforces' moral inequality ... Press has given people we rarely hear from a voice; can we bear to listen?
Press’s cases are diverse and compelling ... by avoiding the seemingly obvious way into the subject, through feminism’s articulation of invisible forms of work, like Arlie Russell Hochschild’s ideas about 'emotional labor' and 'the second shift,' Press occasionally seems to miss opportunities to strengthen his own arguments ... may actually be stronger for the fact it does not make the broadest possible claims based on the data and stories it contains: Despite its low-key, sociological timbre, Press’s reporting contains an unusually high-feeling number of women sources, with whom Press appears to have fostered long-term trust ... By extending the concept of moral injury to the workplaces of millions of workers, Press offers readers a chance to be witnesses too.
... engrossing and frequently enraging ... Press’s lucid narrative is studded with gut-wrenching scenes, including a congressional hearing about the Deepwater Horizon oil rig explosion in which politicians expressed more concern about the disaster’s impact on native bird populations than the deaths of 11 oil workers. This deeply reported and eloquently argued account is a must-read.
A probing investigation ... He closes his account, meaningfully, with a ceremony at a VA hospital in which soldiers confess their 'moral transgressions' while civilians acknowledge, 'We share responsibility with you.' A provocative book that will make readers more aware of terrible things done in their names.
