Offers a passionate case for studying this complex, compelling, now obscure figure ... For readers who’ve ever felt similarly dismissed, the biography may spark a new passion for this connoisseur of women’s interior lives, a writer who could see what many did not.
Brookner is the subject of a new, 500-page book from the tenacious and indefatigable English biographer Hermione Lee. At half the length, Anita Brookner: Art and Life would probably have been twice as good. It is padded out in ways that add drag to its stately propulsion ... Her book is very, very good in places. But because relatively little is known about Brookner’s private life, Lee is forced to search for workarounds to fill the pages. She takes every detour that presents itself ... Consuming this book can be like reading the introduction to a reissue, an introduction that goes on for hundreds of pages. It’s a commonplace compliment to say that a literary biography sends you racing back to read the subject’s work, but this one does the opposite ... Terrific vividness.
Deft and adulatory ... Lee does her best to tell her subject’s story, assembles what facts there are and offers sympathetic readings of the works, while simultaneously exposing one of the great challenges of modern literary biography: What are you supposed to do when the subject does nothing much but write?
Brookner did her utmost to erase her life, and Lee is forced, therefore, to mine any detail she can find ... The tireless details begin to cohere and Brookner steps out of the shadows, intriguing, contradictory ... The older she gets, the more interesting this book becomes ... y “outstanding” novels. Thankfully, it is no longer cool to Brookner-bash. This astute and tireless biography succeeds, against the odds, in unearthing the author – who would be appalled by our scrutiny. Above all, it shows that the work deserves our full attention.
Valiant ... Does the life of a closeted academic...really merit a 544-page book? ... Lee perseveres, bringing to her subject the rigour and authority that have made her lives of Edith Wharton, Virginia Woolf, Penelope Fitzgerald and Tom Stoppard indispensable ... One emerges from Lee’s biography deeply moved, as much by her heroic scholarly endeavour as by the formidable woman she seeks to uncover.
She didn’t make it easy for her future biographer ... Minutiae of this detail is evidence of the issue that bubbles up regularly in the biography: that Lee is having to fill space. In the absence of big life events – all Brookner’s nonroutine travel is dispatched in one paragraph – what else is there? ... It does give the sense that the biography is so much about the books because there’s little to say about the life ... 'How she would have hated having a biography!' Lee writes. But if she must have one, it’s hard to imagine one more loving, careful or worthwhile than this.
Lee gives us many brilliant miniatures of Brookner, with her impeccable maquillage, styled hair and armoured pose ... Piercingly intelligent ... Brookner published 24 novels in almost as many years and Lee writes compellingly about each.
Hermione Lee, one of our best literary biographers, has risen commendably to the challenge. The result is a biography that proves this most recalcitrant of subjects — tenaciously inscrutable, pathologically private and maddeningly obstructive — is also deeply fascinating ... Lee is careful and astute, corroborating what facts she can, refusing to pass judgment on what she cannot. The montage of sketches that emerges is beguiling ... From between the silences, secrets and equivocations emerges a gripping and illuminating portrait of a life dedicated to its art. One likes to think that while she might not have fully approved, Brookner would nevertheless admire the result.