PanLibrary JournalThe volume of research that went into creating Clem’s world is apparent in the novel’s little factual details, like the subcutaneous perfume craze and mentions of the ties between perfume and chemical warfare. In spite of the amount of research and thought Schaffert put into his novel, it disappoints overall. For a book focused on perfume, the sensory descriptions are too few and far between ... While the concept, the characters, and the well-researched details of the setting are intriguing, the plot drags, resulting in an underwhelming read.