Delivered in...measured yet stunning prose. It starts with a repeated phrase, 'they came by way of … ,' which creates a strong musical cadence, guiding the reader through the opening passage like a river current ... This is the terrain of Cormac McCarthy, Pat Mora, Roberto Bolaño, Cristina Rivera Garza and the Mexican poet Jorge Humberto Chávez. Maren’s original descriptions of Ciudad Juárez and El Paso richly add to this literary heritage ... Some of the best-realized parts of the novel describe the intellectual friendships and conversations that develop when Elana and Alex meet a group of Mexican artists who embody a familiar oxymoron: cynical idealists ... Perpetual West is a meditation on a place where the prospect of disappearance and death is a constant fear. The novel is a rebuke to those — especially from the United States — who would romanticize these dangers, or see in the border culture primarily a means of self-discovery. In this respect, Perpetual West is a forceful addition to the literature of the U.S.-Mexican border and its ongoing history of tragedy and joy.
Elana’s search for Alex gives the novel a narrative arc and elevates the tension ... but the heart and soul of Perpetual West dwell in the intersections and conflicts between the psychological struggles of the characters and the frequently staggering cruelty and absurdity of life along the border. Maren is at her best in the minute observation of the culture and rituals of El Paso and Juarez ... The richness and depth of description lends the text authenticity and authority. Mesha Maren is a gifted stylist and a morally serious observer of human frailty. Her intentions are bold, her mastery of language and narrative tension consistently remarkable and occasionally stunning. Simultaneously deep and thrilling, pleasurable and provocative, Perpetual West is a fine next step in the career of a promising talent, as well as a fearless record of a West the world can no longer afford to ignore.
Diving deep into the already fractured relationship between Alex and Elana, Maren has both narrate their triumphs, their fears, and their revelations of the cruelty and beauty of the world around them. Maren employs a sweeping and lyrical narrative voice reminiscent of Sharon Harrigan, Jeffrey Eugenides, and Paulette Jiles and isn’t afraid to let readers sit with the discomfort of addiction, deception, and loss. Immersing readers in areas of Mexico not often seen and peppered with academic inquiries, Perpetual West is nothing short of haunting.
Criticism of historical American expansionism is a subtext of Mesha Maren’s new novel, Perpetual West, which opens with a literal westward movement ... Perpetual West is an engaging tapestry of ideas. It illuminates the flaws of American imperialism as reflected in the manifest destiny doctrine and at the same time sheds light on violence and corruption in Mexico, a problem that the U.S. has in some ways created through our arrogance and insatiable appetite.
The border of El Paso and Juarez is both the physical setting of this novel and its thematic center. At times, Alex and Elana’s position as Americans in Mexico seems to be all-defining, yet their commitment to their own journeys allows them more intimate access. Mesha Maren succeeds in offering readers an insider’s view of impenetrable communities, and Elana’s search for Alex will leave readers breathless.
Meticulously observed ... The ending feels a bit abrupt, but the author does an expert job of showing Elana and Alex’s separate arcs, and their story dramatizes border life in a nonclichéd fashion. It adds up to an admirable if imperfect vehicle for examining the gulf between the two countries’ cultures and people.
