In Good Intentions, Kasim Ali not only lays bare the sweetness and nerves of first love, but also levels an unflinching gaze on the prejudices and racism within minority communities ... This is a complex, tender and bittersweet love story that interrogates familial obligation, religion, race, what it means to be 'good' ... Despite Nur’s belief that he’s in an impossible position, the novel is also incredibly hopeful—maybe our immigrant parents aren’t as immovable as they seem, and perhaps the future holds more choices than we believe. Beautifully written, this will appeal to fans of Caleb Azumah Nelson, Candice Carty-Williams, and Sally Rooney.
Is it worth the fuss? Yes—but with some reservations. Beneath Ali’s overearnest prose is a rather clever novel about vulnerability and victimhood that subtly subverts the reader’s expectations ... This melancholy story shuttles between two timelines five years apart, which eventually converge. Given all the action takes place between 2014 and 2019, it’s interesting Ali chooses not to bring Brexit and the rise of the far right into his narrative. Instead it’s a determinedly intimate story composed of seemingly humdrum conversations that gradually complicate our ideas about Nur ... Initially I was frustrated by Ali’s prose—which can feel sentimental in its descriptions of Nur’s angst. But it skilfully lulls us into thinking of him as helpless before showing the dangers of an overdeveloped persecution complex. On the surface Good Intentions is a poignant romance about the cultural barriers that stand in the way of two young people pursuing an honest relationship. Yet beneath there is a cautionary tale about what happens when you get so caught up in your own vulnerability that you forget your responsibility to others.
There is something of a Sally Rooney vibe to this story about twentysomethings navigating adult waters (the snappy dialogue, the conflicted emotions, the relationship dramas), but Ali’s novel veers off on a darker course as questions of race and culture threaten to undermine a once solid love. This timely, savvy novel is recommended.
As Ali tackles the difficult reality of racism within ethnic groups tied to assumptions of solidarity, he succinctly delineates memorable characters and complex interactions. The narrative’s leaps back and forward in time can be challenging, even as they serve to escalate the tension of Nur’s damaging choices. In all, a vitally important exploration of deep-rooted prejudice, and the disconnect between understanding and the genuine practice of inclusiveness.
... alluring ... It’s fairly familiar terrain, but well-drawn supporting characters such as Nur’s gay Muslim friend Imran round out this thoughtful portrait of young people weighing the bonds of tradition with personal identity. Readers will root for this imperfect love until the end.
Ali's novel explores the ways that racism may do its insidious damage even among those who are traditionally not its targets and victims. Despite Nur's sense that he's impeccably right-minded and anti-racist, despite the fact that he truly loves Yasmina and wants to make his life with her, his insistence on putting off and putting off telling his family about his beloved may be less a realist's acknowledgment of the racism in the world than a kind of accommodation of or even collusion with it. An exploration of the ways that race and family ties may complicate or imperil romance even if everyone means well.