Hanley is back with [a]...compelling and groundbreaking narrative history of the Korean War ... An extraordinary kaleidoscope of human experiences in a catastrophic forgotten war.
As Mr. Hanley’s narrative gathers force, he seeks to share out the blame equally between the two sides—or, as he terms them, 'the communist and capitalist powers'—for the war’s staggering record of suffering. Whether he makes his case persuasively is doubtful, but he does manage to show that all wars are hell, not least the forgotten ones ... Mr. Hanley’s granular approach, which makes such compelling reading, leaves aside the larger issues involved. In the end, Ghost Flames resembles a series of police reports rather than a work of history. Mr. Hanley delves into the darker recesses of this conflict without shedding light on why it was happening ... 'War is the worst thing in the world,' Ridgway said when the fighting in Korea stopped at the end of July 1953. Mr. Hanley’s harrowing account, in all its vivid detail, confirms that judgment while stopping short of measuring with similar precision why some wars are worth fighting all the same.
The book is a fast and engrossing haunting read that thoroughly educates while pulling on the heart strings. It blends military campaigns with real politic, while never losing sight of the people in the context of the immorality and savagery of war.
It is by its nature incomplete and anecdotal. While it reveals a part of the war that is often left out of conventional histories, by being selective it can distort history ... His journalistic approach to history reveals some trees, ignores others, while hiding the forest.
In this sweeping and well-sourced history, Associated Press reporter Hanley...captures the devastating human toll of the Korean War ... Hanley paints an extraordinary portrait of the war’s complexity and devastation. This is an essential account of America’s 'forgotten war.'
A Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist forges a masterly new history of the Korean War ... his journalistic talents are on full display in his latest book. He also demonstrates a novelist’s touch and a wonderful ear for dialogue and detail ... The accretion of astounding detail makes for a vivid, multilayered look at a deeply complicated war in which few emerged as heroic. A top-notch addition to the literature on the Korean War.
