The strategy falls flat. By only choosing the most important days, Hunter is trying to have it both ways: to immerse us in the inner world of a single character but keep the action spicy too. The result is that neither really comes off ... Many readers will enjoy the images of genuine lyrical beauty in Days of Light...but the novel concludes in the same state of suspension that Ivy was experiencing on page 1. It was odd: I spent six decades with a character but finished the book feeling that I didn’t know her at all.
The early parts of the novel are a vividly immersive delight ... As the years pass, though, the book loses some of its early momentum. Novels like David Nicholls’s One Day may make it look easy, but a satisfying narrative that contains itself to only a handful of days is extremely hard to pull off.
