Terrific fun ... But Harkaway also exposes the deep-seated prejudices that infected America’s intelligence establishment and thwarted its effectiveness ... Harkaway, like his dad, plots with the kind of density that I suspect is close to real spycraft: more paper chase than car chase ... But as much as The Taper Man has John le Carré’s nose, it’s got Harkaway’s face. His plotting and style offer an homage without imitating Dad. That’s most evident in the novel’s singular tone. Hold this book to a flame, and you can see a line of wit written across these pages in invisible ink.
Writers who have famous authors for parents might view it as an inhibiting burden, but Nick Harkaway, the son of John le Carré, has seen it as an opportunity, which he has seized with a confidence that has proved entirely justified ... The narrative alternates between Smiley and Bland, and this makes for a complicated book, with two sets of suspects to remember, two strongly plotted but complex stories to digest. The Bland chapters are not as gripping as those of Smiley ... The writing throughout is evocative and adroit, though there are occasional signs of haste. This new tranche of Le Carré/Harkaway fiction does not need to multiply quickly to retain our interest. It will only lose it if the quality of the books suffers from a rush to capitalise on the franchise. Avoiding that, for a writer as talented as Harkaway, should just be a matter of him taking his time.
The conclusion, as in most of the Circus novels, is anything but conclusive, but Harkaway exhibits his father’s knack for slow reveals, complex storylines, and salient observations about human nature. George Smiley is in good hands.
Readers who can follow, much less predict, every turn in this densely plotted installment are invited to submit their applications to their own national intelligence service. The Cold War has never felt hotter.