The graphic novel juggles the sometimes harsh realities of the outside world and the magic of the performances on stage. There is drug abuse, robberies and riots—but the overall outlook remains upbeat. Like a biopic, the second act is filled with highs and lows ... sobering moments balance the euphoria of other events, like the live recording of a 1963 album by James Brown ... smartly placed newspaper clippings...move the story along ... the third act delivers the start of a happy ending ... Order is restored...with a multitude of lights.
The carefully researched narrative features those who worked and performed at the Apollo over the years and strives to portray the good times as well as the bad. Smith's...dynamic artwork often eschews traditional comics panels in favor of images and scenes that flow together, conveying the energy and excitement of showbiz. The two-tone, black-and-blue coloring creates the feeling of being inside a darkened theater, although it could have benefited from occasional splashes of contrasting hues. And while the amount of information presented can be almost overwhelming, the work ultimately accomplishes its goal of relaying the Apollo's status as a legendary venue ... Anyone interested in African American music and history and pop culture history will find this a captivating read.
The voices in this book are almost uniformly boosterish about their theater because it truly feels like their theater, even if it was owned by white guys for much of its history. Fox echoes their enthusiasm, skimming briskly past the bleak parts—from cockroaches in the dressing rooms to riots out in the streets. Smith's art has a similar mythmaking quality—all his depictions of the Apollo's performers are iconic. He draws these entertainers at their best possible moments, just as they'd like to see themselves. Though he captures numerous electrifying onstage scenes, he softens the showbiz lifestyle's gritty side. These are understandable choices, but they result in a book that's too invested in its own myths to be a great read. That may be the only way to write about the Apollo, though ... It's shame Fox and Smith couldn't explore this potent mix [of 'shame and desperation'] more thoroughly ... But at the Apollo, hope is always the heart of the dish.
Smith’s exuberant lines ably transmit the book’s dense energy, as though the narrative is at risk of breaking its bounds, but his thin, rough characterizations don’t always do justice to the material. This is a vibrant, exultant, and soulful history.
This graphic treatment adds a new dimension to a music book that was already hailed as a classic ... This collaboration between Fox...and illustrator Smith represents a new experience for readers, one with an immediacy and vitality that text alone might never approach ... Fox and Smith effectively present the progression of entertainment styles from swing and tap dance through bebop, gospel and blues, rhythm & blues, soul, and rock. They provide an entertaining, lively narrative with profiles that match the spirit, drawings that seem as musical as the music described within the text. The renewal of spirit through this striking collaboration reflects the way the Apollo has renewed itself through the decades.
