Queen of Bebop depicts Vaughan as a musician's musician, tougher than the rest. As a singer and piano player, she took to the challenging structures of bebop as if she'd made up the modes herself ... Queen of Bebop adds detail to aspects of Vaughan's life that confounded even her most besotted fans. The music critics, disc jockeys and promoters who championed her work early on became frustrated with Vaughan the jazz singer vs. Vaughan the pop singer ... But Hayes offers little fresh insight into controversial decisions over which Vaughan had complete control — particularly in the hiring of inexperienced husbands and lovers to represent her in business ... Queen of Bebop is a welcome and well-researched accounting of Vaughan's life story. It's also a testament to the singularity of her talent. But perhaps the book's greatest accomplishment will be more ears on Vaughan's music.
It reads like a graceful doctoral dissertation, sensitive to Vaughan’s technical gifts and the development of her art. But it goes awry in its attempt to politicize her as a civil rights and feminist groundbreaker — as though her artistic stature alone would not have justified this book ... Overtheorizing strains her study of the featherweight hits Vaughan recorded in the ’50s for her new label, Mercury ... Despite what the author states, Vaughan was no 'race woman'; she was not inclined to march, campaign or crusade. Her racial significance is more that of a high-achieving, abundantly talented black woman who inspired by example ... Her true legacy was summed up to me by the jazz singer Dianne Reeves, who recalled her first response to Vaughan: “You mean, there are those kinds of possibilities?” On that score, “Queen of Bebop” leaves no doubt.
This comprehensive examination of Vaughan’s life and work benefits from Hayes’s technical knowledge of music and her thorough research on the historical context ... Following that crossover journey yields a solid narrative that documents Vaughan’s struggles, triumphs and unprecedented success as a 'symphonic diva, singing jazz in venues previously reserved for classical music and opera'...While useful for organizing a linear narrative of Vaughan’s career, one of the unfortunate limitations of this approach is a devaluation of the so-called obscure period ... Hayes does an especially good job of explaining the musical landscape of postwar white America ... while drug use and bad relationships are a reality, they do not dominate Hayes’s presentation of Vaughan’s life; they do not take away from the centrality and enormity of her talent and musical contribution. This is as it should be.
Hayes argues that Vaughan’s refusal to let herself be pigeonholed as a happy-go-lucky swinger, blues-drenched victim or romantic pop crooner, but instead embraced all sides of her artistic personality, allowed Vaughan to transcend stereotypical expectations of race and gender...Though Hayes offers no evidence to back up this rather grand assertion, her strategy of viewing Vaughan through the lenses of race and gender leads to some profitable insights ... But Hayes displays a disappointing level of fluency in jazz history, its African-American milieu and the fickle machinations of the popular music business ... while Queen of Bebop sheds welcome new light on Vaughan, jazz fans will still have to wait for a definitive biography of this important figure.
Hayes’ labored explanation of how [local DJ] Dave Garroway 'broke the rules' by describing Vaughan’s voice in terms usually reserved for white women is regrettably typical of her tendency to shoehorn academic analysis of race and gender issues into a text supposedly aimed at general readers. Her points are perfectly valid, but the way she makes them is dreary. However, Hayes does a capable job of outlining Vaughan’s career, hampered both artistically and financially by her unfortunate predilection for letting the men in her life manage her ... Informative and well-intentioned but sometimes pedestrian and lacking the elegant effervescence of Vaughan’s singing.
The author knows music and is good at explaining, inasmuch as such talent can be explained, the qualities that made Vaughan's 'the most talked-about voice in America' ...author is sure-footed around the cutthroat world of clubs, record producers, shady agents and manipulative, overbearing managers, three of whom Sarah married, to her almost immediate regret. The book tracks her roller-coaster career through the ups and downs... Readers will also have to negotiate a certain amount of heavy-handed explaining on the role of racism and sexism in the music business and in American life generally.
...a lively and moving portrait of the passionate and tenacious jazz singer. Hayes gracefully narrates Vaughan’s life ... Hayes’s blending of the cultural history of the 1950s, ’60s, and ’70s with his lucid critical insights into Vaughan’s recordings and her life makes this book a detailed look at a fearless singer who constantly moved into new musical territories and left a legacy for younger musicians.
