One [character] will remind readers of Norman Bates long before King name-checks Psycho. Alas, Never Flinch never captivated me because of that disagreeable precedent. Not only was Norman’s psychosis based on dubious psychological principles, but Alfred Hitchcock’s homophobic representation of him also established a template for demeaning representations of gender-variant villains that persists to this day. King enters this fray with more empathy than most, but one wonders why he decided to go there at all ... King never grants his gender-ambivalent killer the depth or dignity he confers on other classic bugaboos. We never learn why gender dysphoria drove this person insane, and their origin story doesn’t honor their individuality ... Reading his 21st-century novels, I’ve often gotten the sense that King is sincerely attempting to compensate for some of the sexism, homophobia and racism of his early work. He hasn’t yet crafted a fully believable queer or trans character, however, and that shortcoming stands out in Never Flinch ... [An] open-minded worldview has been King’s stock in trade for more than 50 years, which makes Holly the quintessential King protagonist and her stories a great entry point into King’s work for new readers ... King is one of the best genre novelists writing today, so to say that Never Flinch isn’t as good as Holly or The Outsider is like saying that Cannery Row isn’t as good as The Grapes of Wrath. As with all King novels, its propulsive plot will keep you turning pages long past your bedtime. His evocative prose still makes characters come alive and ensures that they linger long after their stories are over. Never Flinch has a serious shortcoming that some readers might find offensive. I am one of them, and I still couldn’t put it down.

[King] could write the book equivalent of bubble wrap and I would still want to read it, but what is delivered—swathed in shipping material—sometimes fails to meet expectations. Unfortunately, that’s the case with King’s latest ... With Never Flinch, Holly’s growth as a character comes to a screeching halt ... Holly hits the road with the activist and brings along a gun, despite her deep need to be near her home and her abhorrence of weapons. Motivation is problematic, to say the least ... The stalker-serial killer story lines beggar belief, too, and other recurring characters seem to be here just so they can be kidnapped ... In the afterword, King admits even his wife told him he could 'do better' after reading the first draft. Three rewrites later and he’s 'happy enough' with the version for publication. And he’s right. It is enough, but Holly deserved something more.

Complications follow complications, unexpected events disrupt carefully laid plans, murder follows murder, and, shifting nimbly between the two story lines, King keeps us in a constant state of edge-of-our-seat suspense. Ms. Gibney continues to be a deeply interesting and likable character, and the author has created one of his most twistedly compelling villains. This is Stephen King at his finest, and an absolute must-read for his fans.

The author succeeds in grabbing the reader’s interest and holding it throughout this page-turning tale of terror, which reads like a big-screen thriller. The action is well paced, the settings are vividly drawn, and King’s choice to focus on the real and deadly dangers of extremist thought is admirable. But the book is hamstrung by cliched characters, hackneyed dialogue (both spoken and internal), and motives that feel both convoluted and overly simplistic. King shines brightest when he gets to the heart of our darkest fears and desires, but here the dangers seem a bit cerebral ... Even when King is not at his best, he’s still good.

King cements PI Holly Gibney’s status as one of the great contemporary detectives in this thrilling sequel to Holly ... Holly shines as a quirky but lovable beacon of hope amid the plot’s grisly violence, and King never lets his Rube Goldberg–esque plot overshadow his characters’ humanity. Elegantly structured and sharply written, this moody mystery from the master of horror is a must-read.