While the passages involving Lucía are so vivid they can be hard to get through, it is the depiction of the narrator’s relationships with her charges...that gives the novel its most powerful emotional oomph ... Beautifully, intricately rendered ... The novel’s second and third sections lack the organizing structure of the first, surrendering less to plot than to the possibility of it ... The narrative is often tripped up by bizarre...and other times feels far too deliberate, like misplaced poetry ... These are small stumbles in an otherwise affecting book, but it’s hard not to pay attention to such wobbliness at the line level when readers must tag along with the narrator to her creative writing workshops ... Overall, Nanny Nanny is a sharp and sincere portrait of the gray areas between survival and triumph, of the complications of families both chosen and given, of the possibilities for joy and heartbreak inherent in the desire to procreate.
Brutality is the cornerstone of Chiucarello’s Nanny Nanny ... Nanny Nanny presents, at its sharpest, a nauseating autopsy of marital abuse, one that likens the self-abandoning imperatives of parenthood to those that leave the narrator open to intimate harm.
Searing ... From the extreme to the everyday, with mesmeric specificity, Chiucarello writes of the life that unfolds behind closed doors: both the kind of violence that leads the nanny to call 911, and her tender care of young children. Family, love, language, and the failures of all three dominate this wisely voiced, sensitively self-propelling, and continuously surprising novel.
Clear-eyed ... Chiucarello brings the character to life as a three-dimensional figure, not a victim. It’s a sharp-edged look at how trauma shapes but doesn’t define a life.