Extraordinary ... Trey’s also a lively narrator, and he folds these adages neatly into his adventures. The footnotes distract from the story at times, but never derail it, because the story is consistently engrossing ... It shines a vivid light onto underappreciated aspects of our history. However, the book’s greatest charm lies in the sensitivity and subtlety of its narrative ... Trey never loses his sense of humor, and one can’t help rooting for him as he matures with each chapter ... This book could be taught in schools.
... vibrant ... At one point, Trey admits that among Rustin’s recommended books, he’s able to grasp the biographies but has a hard time with political theory. It appears that the book in our hands is the one he wrote for young people like himself who may also need to learn even as they throw themselves into activist work. Who provided the annotations, which are full of historical context, is less clear; even though they’re helpful — mainly to an audience less familiar with both Black and queer history — they aren’t utilized as well as they might be for a full meta-textual effect. But that’s a small flaw in an otherwise marvelous read ... The book is also a love letter to activism, which isn’t to say it glamorizes it — quite the opposite ... To the well-versed in the era’s politics, the many luminaries Trey meets and the historic events he finds himself at the center of might seem far-fetched, but there’s a sense that Newson is winking at those of us in the know, inviting us into that space of wondering what we might have done or failed to do if we had lived then and there. And as for the majority of readers, the book provides a crash course in the history of a pivotal era via a vividly imagined lived experience. Much like Trey being schooled by Rustin 'with such a light touch,' readers of My Government Means to Kill Me may not even realize they’re 'getting smarter about gay culture and politics.'
A historical work seemingly written with an eye toward the future, this copiously footnoted novel numbers prominent figures of the time among its characters and namechecks others...Unfortunately, the raw, powerful immediacy of the novel is too often interrupted by a didactic distraction that mostly functions to distance the reader from the action, but Newson’s reputation as a TV writer/showrunner (Bel-Air) will attract attention.
The most notable aspect of My Government Means to Kill Me is the presence of historical figures at key points in the story...Newson weaves important civil rights and LGBTQ+ activists such as Dorothy Cotton and Larry Kramer into the narrative to bolster Trey's development...As Trey becomes a founding member of the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power (ACT UP), readers get a glimpse into the rich and boisterous political environment of the '80s...Newsom balances these moments of representation and recognition with appearances from more nefarious figures like 'racist slumlord' Fred Trump, who tries to evict Trey and his friends from their home...Newson capitalizes on the many powers of historical fiction while ensuring that Trey's story never becomes stuffy or predictable...My Government Means to Kill Me is proof that writers can revere and play with history at the same time.
TV writer and producer Newson debuts with a crisp fictitious memoir of a gay Black man’s coming-of-age in mid-1980s New York City...Though the choice to frame this as a memoir remains a bit curious, as doing so doesn’t add much to the narrative, Newson can turn a sharp phrase (a job loss teaches Trey that 'affection never outlasted need'), and his footnotes to historic figures provide context and nuance ('A list of his undeniable accomplishments could only be rivaled in length by a list of the names of other LGBTQ+ activists with whom he clashed, offended, and rebuked,' he writes of Larry Kramer)...It adds up to an eloquent story of the struggle for gay liberation.
