Wonderful and bewitching ... Li is in complete command of her complicated, probing narrative here ... It’s the kind of sui generis novel that doesn’t come around that often, just like the virtuosos whose young lives it explores.
With elegant symmetry and a cool, genteel prose style, Ms. Li tracks these parallel stories, exploring the duo’s worldly educations and the ruthless sacrifices to love and friendship they make in pursuit of their ambitions ... The novel is so doctrinaire about its pessimism that it mostly neglects the characters’ music. The moments are rare—and therefore gratefully encountered—when John and Adelaide are permitted to take pleasure in the 'pure joy' of their playing.
Fascinating ... Sharp and thoughtfully rendered, Li’s novel reckons with the costs of artistic greatness on the families who make sacrifices to accommodate genius and the artists who fear being forgotten. It’s a remarkable achievement.
