Skillfully edited ... The book is an unfiltered history of the transition from the old Hollywood studio system over to a new, more director-centered system, written by a participant in the change ... Bogdanovich’s writing has voice, giving everything flavor and displaying the personality of a gloriously opinionated 20th-century hustler ... Shows up close and personal how movies can take over the mind and heart—and complete life—of a smart and talented man.
The book tells—in an unusual format—the extraordinary personal story of Bogdanovich’s many achievements in the nineteen-sixties and the early seventies ... The story of an aesthetic education and a sentimental one; it’s a work of history and a real-time bildungsroman.
A first-person narration of a young striver’s breaking in ... If nothing else, these pages bear record to the whirlwind of activities that Bogdanovich engaged in during the six-year period covered herein ... The fact is, however, with all of the eager beaver-ish activity of any given day, Bogdanovich is often a perfunctory diarist at best, and large swaths of But What I Really Want to Do Is Direct are not much more revealing than would be an appointment book ... By virtue of their repeated appearances on the stage of Young Bogdanovich’s life, certain characters get a bit more shading and contouring ... While it may seem a bit much to ask for the prose of a private journal to rise to the level of fine-tuned, belle-lettrist literature—we can’t all be Helen Garner—but if it shouldn’t, one at the very least could supply some scandalous and salacious tidbits to justify their publication.
Revelatory ... Because the book draws from Bogdanovich’s own writings, it is perhaps more honest and self-analytical than any biography could be; here, we see the filmmaker laid bare, and we gain a whole new appreciation for the films he made.