Johnston stands out for her attunement to the needs and anxieties of true beginners—particularly those who are women, for whom pumping iron often requires a certain amount of unlearning ... Johnston’s assertion that lifting 'completely changed how I think and feel about the world and myself and everything' sounds like another of the fitness industry’s wild overpromises. But I know what she means. I, too, have found that lifting can transform the way you relate to your body ... Weight lifting has stuck, for me and I think for Johnston, because it can also change the way one thinks about achievement. It serves as a pretty good metaphor for a balanced approach to striving that eschews both the Lean In–girlboss hustle and its 'I don’t dream of labor' anti-ambition backlash.
Reads as nothing short of a revelation ... There is, in that sense, something misaligned about the plotted awakening that Johnston charts in her book, whose plain sentences conform to the recognizable beats of 'before' and 'after'... A note in the back of A Physical —'My story is not your story'—sounds a bit like the disclaimer on a weight-loss ad: 'Results may vary.'
Openhearted ... Johnston, who adopted the practice, effectively simplifies the science of weight lifting for a layperson, and peppers the narrative with charming anecdotes that chart her growing strength—most memorably when she beat three male friends in an arm-wrestling contest. It’s an empowering resource for women curious about weight lifting.
