MixedThe NationKlosterman is vulnerable and effusive in a way that captures how fandom feels ... But the logic of his arguments falls apart because it stays firmly within that emotional framework ... The thing with obituaries, especially public ones, is that more often than not, they sanitize their subjects. People don’t like to speak ill of the dead. Klosterman’s book is no different: In this public performance of future mourning, he reduces the sport to its clichés.
Alexis Pauline Gumbs
PositiveThe Washington PostIt often reads like a collection of essays intended to continue Lorde’s own project of self-mythologizing ... There are also many places where Gumbs hypothesizes when there’s a lack of information, which then becomes an exercise of imaginatively expanding the idea of Lorde, rather than documenting her life ... Though these elisions and inventions are shortcomings, they also speak to the book’s worthwhile attempt to change what a biography can be ... By recounting Lorde’s story outside linear chronology, and putting her alongside the rivers, forests, radio waves and obsidian, Gumbs is faithful to her subject’s great desire to be something more eternal. But Survival Is a Promise finally shows that this cosmic life is achieved through grounded and deep human work.
