PositiveNew York Times Book Review[A] subtle, resonant debut novel ... One of many feats of narrative restraint that Luchette uses expertly throughout the book: Mundane turning points, muted as prayer, subtly plant the seeds of Agatha’s quiet journey to apostasy ... The power and pleasure of this novel lie in the slow blooming of desire from tiny seeds of doubt.
MixedThe New York Times Book ReviewSurprisingly, given Winslow’s career writing crime fiction, there’s nothing novelistic about the way this memoir unfolds. The detectives and prosecutors who emerge as significant supporting characters are given scant descriptions. Settings are all but invisible. Instead, the focus is on the finer points of law enforcement procedure, with every excruciating moment of the process painstakingly recounted. While much of this is bureaucratic, even tedious, Winslow attempts to inject drama with explosive bits of dialogue and many short, declarative stand-alone sentences, a device repeated to diminishing effect ... [a] meticulously constructed and ultimately terrifying memoir.
RaveThe New York Times Book Review...a searing narrative that plumbs both emotional and political depths ... Connors’s forthright exploration of race and poverty enlarges her personal story, turning it into a richer, more complex and ultimately more harrowing account of interwoven traumas ... What’s miraculous about this memoir is Connors’s ability to identify, in clean, lucid prose, evidence of hope — and even beauty — amid such an abundance of misery.