RaveHistorical Novel SocietyMontclair has drawn some of the most interesting characters—intriguing, unusual yet totally believable—to populate this novel ... The plot moves quickly, well-paced with unexpected twists. There are moments of light-heartedness and moments of deep emotion, adding depth and dimension and lifting this book well out of the field of run-of-the-mill historical mysteries. The dialogue is fast-paced and funny, with some of the best one-liners I’ve seen in a novel. And throughout the voice and tone are—well—cheeky ... Montclair succeeds ... I’ll be first in line for her next book.
Nick Dybek
PositiveHistorical Novel SocietyWhile there are obvious comparisons to The English Patient, this book seems to be an extended metaphor showing how relationships, loves even, can be shattered beyond all recognition, just as a human body can be obliterated. [Dybek] effectively communicates the spirit of place and time. He also has a knack for sharing the feelings and intentions behind quite ordinary conversations. The strength of this book lies in the first chapters set in Verdun. The powerful images of post-war suffering eclipse the image of long-dead romances.
